Melbourne | Geelong | Warrnambool
Melbourne | Geelong | Warrnambool
Complete your details below or call us now on (03) 9070 9885 to book your free consultation. For all urgent, after-hours enquiries call or SMS us on 0403613515
Murder charges in Australia are the most serious criminal allegations a person can face. A charge of this nature carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. It triggers a court process that is lengthy, complex, and high-stakes from the first moment. Understanding what murder charges involve and how the legal process works can help you or someone close to you navigate an extraordinarily difficult situation. The criminal lawyers at Gallant Law regularly represent clients in homicide matters across Victoria, including the Supreme Court of Victoria.
This article covers the legal definition of murder under Victorian law, the elements the prosecution must prove, and how murder differs from manslaughter. It also explains the court process and what to do if you or someone close to you is under investigation or has been charged.
Key Takeaways
Murder charges in Victoria are governed by the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic). Under that Act, murder is established where a person causes the death of another and at the time of the killing intended to kill, intended to cause grievous bodily harm, or acted with reckless indifference to human life.
Murder charges, therefore, capture three distinct states of mind. Each carries the same charge and the same maximum penalty, but the mental element the prosecution relies on affects how the case is run and what defences may be available.
The most straightforward form of murder involves proof that the accused intended to bring about the death of the victim. This is direct intent. The prosecution must establish that death was the accused’s purpose, not merely a likely outcome of their conduct.
Intent can be inferred from circumstances. Intent can be inferred from the weapon used, the nature of the attack, and statements made before or after the death. The conduct of the accused immediately following the death is also relevant.
A person can be found guilty of murder even without intending to kill if they intended to cause grievous bodily harm, meaning really serious harm, and death resulted. This is a common basis for murder charges where a violent assault leads to a death, the accused may claim was unintended.
Courts have held that where a person inflicts serious violence knowing it carries a real risk of death, murder intent can be established even if death itself was not the aim.
The third limb of murder charges arises where the accused acted with reckless indifference to human life. This means the accused foresaw that death was a probable consequence of their conduct and proceeded regardless. The High Court case of R v Crabbe established key principles on recklessness in murder that continue to guide Victorian courts.
Reckless indifference is a higher standard than negligence. The accused must have turned their mind to the possibility of death as a likely outcome. This distinguishes murder from manslaughter, where the mental element is lower.
Murder charges and manslaughter both involve the unlawful killing of a person. The critical difference is the mental element. Murder requires proof of intent to kill, intent to cause grievous bodily harm, or reckless indifference to human life. Manslaughter does not.
Manslaughter arises in two main forms. Voluntary manslaughter applies where a person intended to cause harm, but circumstances such as provocation, excessive self-defence, or diminished responsibility reduce the charge. Involuntary manslaughter applies where a person caused death through criminal negligence or an unlawful, dangerous act, without the intent required for murder.
Murder charges can be reduced to manslaughter at two points. The prosecution may accept a plea to manslaughter. A jury may also return a verdict of not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter as an alternative.
The difference in penalty is significant. Manslaughter carries a maximum of 25 years’ imprisonment in Victoria, compared to life imprisonment for murder. Courts also have far greater discretion in sentencing for manslaughter, with outcomes ranging from suspended sentences to lengthy custodial terms depending on the circumstances.
Victorian law recognises partial defences that, if successful, reduce murder to manslaughter rather than resulting in an acquittal. These include excessive self-defence, where a person used force that was disproportionate to the threat but genuinely believed they were acting in self-defence.
A complete defence, such as full self-defence, if accepted, results in an acquittal. Where the accused acted in genuine and reasonable self-defence, they are not guilty of any offence. These defences require careful analysis of the evidence and skilled advocacy to run effectively.
Murder charges trigger an immediate and serious legal process. If you or someone close to you has been charged, getting experienced criminal defence lawyers in Melbourne involved from the very first moment is critical. Here is what the process typically involves.
A person charged with murder is typically arrested and brought to a police station. You have the right to silence. You are not obliged to answer police questions, and no adverse inference can be drawn from your silence in Victoria. Exercising your right to silence before speaking with a lawyer is strongly advisable.
Police will often want to conduct a formal recorded interview. Anything said in that interview can be used as evidence at trial. A criminal lawyer should be present, and you should always receive advice before agreeing to answer questions.
Bail for murder charges is rare. Courts presiding over serious charges apply a presumption against bail. To obtain bail, the accused must demonstrate exceptional circumstances. A lawyer can make a bail application to the Supreme Court, but the prospects depend heavily on the individual circumstances of the case.
Where bail is refused, the accused remains in custody on remand until the matter is finalised. This can be a period of one to three years for complex homicide matters. Gallant Law appears at urgent bail hearings and understands what courts require to even consider bail in murder matters.
Murder charges begin in the Magistrates’ Court and are committed to the Supreme Court of Victoria for trial. A committal hearing tests whether there is sufficient evidence for the case to proceed. The defence can cross-examine key prosecution witnesses at this stage. This is a valuable opportunity to test the strength of the case and identify weaknesses in the evidence. We can also elicit further important evidence from key witnesses.
The committal stage also allows the defence to apply to have certain charges or evidence excluded before the matter reaches the Supreme Court. How this stage is handled can significantly affect the conduct of the trial.
Murder trials are heard before a judge and jury in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The jury must reach a unanimous verdict. Prosecution counsel opens, calls witnesses, and presents the evidence. Defence counsel then has the opportunity to challenge that evidence, call its own witnesses, and make submissions to the jury.
A murder trial can run for several weeks or longer in complex matters. The verdict is delivered by the jury foreperson. If the jury cannot reach a unanimous verdict, a hung jury may result in a retrial.
Facing murder charges is the most serious situation a person can encounter in the criminal justice system. Gallant Law’s team is available seven days a week. Call (03) 9070 9885 or contact us online for urgent advice.
Murder carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment under the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic). According to the Sentencing Advisory Council, murder consistently results in custodial sentences in Victoria’s Supreme Court. Non-parole periods for murder convictions commonly range from 18 to 30 years, though this varies significantly with the circumstances.
A life sentence does not mean a person will spend the rest of their life in prison in every case. The court sets a non-parole period, which is the minimum time the person must serve before becoming eligible for parole. For murder, non-parole periods are long.
Where a murder was particularly brutal, involved a vulnerable victim, or was premeditated over an extended period, courts impose longer non-parole periods. Mitigating factors such as an early guilty plea, demonstrated remorse, youth, and the absence of prior criminal history can reduce the non-parole period.
In exceptional cases, where the offender poses an ongoing serious danger to the community, the court may impose an indefinite sentence with no fixed non-parole period. This is reserved for the most serious repeat offenders and is rarely imposed.
In Victoria, a guilty plea at an early stage attracts a sentencing discount of up to 25 per cent. For murder charges carrying a life maximum, this can translate to a significantly shorter non-parole period. A defence lawyer assesses the evidence and advises honestly on whether a guilty plea is appropriate and what benefit it is likely to achieve.
Murder charges are not the time for a generalist approach. The stakes could not be higher. Gallant Law’s Principal, Lauren Cassimatis, is a Law Institute of Victoria Accredited Specialist in Criminal Law. She brings over 20 years of experience in serious criminal matters, including homicide proceedings in Victoria’s higher courts. Our team has appeared in the Supreme Court and County Court, representing clients across Melbourne, Geelong, Ballarat, Warrnambool, and throughout regional Victoria.
A murder defence is built over months. The brief of evidence is large and must be reviewed in full. Forensic material must be assessed, expert witnesses may need to be briefed, and every aspect of the prosecution case must be scrutinised. Starting that process on the day of arrest, not weeks later, makes a material difference.
Gallant Law begins work on a defence from the first call. We advise on whether to answer police questions, we appear at bail hearings, we engage with the prosecution during the committal process, and we prepare submissions and briefings for the trial.
Murder prosecutions rely on a range of evidence: forensic material, surveillance footage, phone records, witness statements, and expert opinion. Each category can be challenged. Forensic evidence must meet strict collection and analysis standards. Witnesses can be tested under cross-examination. Expert opinion can be countered by independent experts retained by the defence.
An experienced criminal lawyer identifies where the prosecution case is weakest and builds the defence around those vulnerabilities.
If you or someone you know is facing murder charges, take these steps straight away. This also applies if police have indicated they wish to speak with someone about a homicide investigation. Do not answer police questions without a lawyer present. Do not speak to anyone about the matter other than your lawyer. Contact Gallant Law straight away on (03) 9070 9885. We are available seven days a week for urgent matters.
Murder charges represent the most serious point in the criminal justice system. The legal process is long, the evidence complex, and the consequences of a conviction life-altering. Understanding the elements of the charge, the court process, and the available defences is the first step toward navigating what lies ahead.
Gallant Law provides experienced, specialist criminal defence for homicide matters across Victoria. If you need urgent advice about murder charges, contact our team on (03) 9070 9885 or through our website.
To establish murder charges in Victoria, the prosecution must prove that the accused caused the death of another person, and that at the time they intended to kill, intended to cause grievous bodily harm, or acted with reckless indifference to human life. All elements must be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Yes. Murder charges can be reduced to manslaughter if the prosecution accepts a plea. A jury may also return a verdict of not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Manslaughter carries a lower maximum penalty, and courts have greater sentencing discretion. Whether this outcome is achievable depends entirely on the facts of the case.
Murder charges in Victoria are ultimately heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria before a judge and jury. The matter begins in the Magistrates’ Court for a committal hearing before being transferred to the Supreme Court. This process typically takes one to two years or longer.
The maximum penalty for murder in Victoria is life imprisonment. Courts set a non-parole period, which is the minimum time to be served before parole eligibility. Non-parole periods for murder commonly range from 18 to 30 years, depending on the circumstances of the offending, the offender’s history, and any mitigating factors.
No. You have the right to silence in Victoria, and exercising it is not evidence of guilt. Contact a criminal lawyer immediately before speaking to police about any homicide matter. What you say in a police interview can and will be used as evidence at trial.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Builders should obtain advice specific to their circumstances before making decisions relating to licensing arrangements or contact an experienced law firm for professional advice.
Article by Lauren Cassimatis – Principal Lawyer
Meet Lauren Cassimatis
Principal Lawyer, Director & Founder | Accredited Criminal Law Specialist
Lauren is one of Victoria’s leading criminal lawyers and a Law Institute of Victoria Accredited Specialist in Criminal Law.
